top of page

Differences between NBCC and ASCE 7 in Structural Performance Categories and Design Requirements

The National Building Code of Canada (NBCC) and the American Society of Civil Engineers' ASCE 7 Standard are two widely adopted guidelines for seismic design. Both standards aim to ensure the safety and performance of structures during seismic events, but their approaches to structural performance categories and design requirements differ. This article discusses the distinctions between NBCC and ASCE 7 in terms of structural performance categories and design requirements, focusing on the fundamental principles that guide the design and construction of structures.


Structural Performance Categories

NBCC: The NBCC does not explicitly define structural performance categories. Instead, it uses a single set of performance criteria and force-based design methods for all types of structures, regardless of their location or importance.

ASCE 7: ASCE 7 establishes different structural performance categories based on the structure's importance, occupancy, and location. The standard defines four performance categories (A, B, C, and D), each with specific design requirements that ensure an appropriate level of safety and performance during seismic events.


Design Requirements Based on Performance Categories

NBCC: Since the NBCC does not define structural performance categories, the design requirements are uniform for all structures. The standard focuses on life safety and property protection, with the objective of minimizing structural damage during seismic events.

ASCE 7: ASCE 7 tailors design requirements for each structural performance category. Structures in higher performance categories have more stringent design requirements to ensure greater safety and performance during seismic events. This approach allows for better prioritization of resources and improved resilience in critical structures.


Seismic Design Parameters

NBCC: The NBCC uses a single set of seismic design parameters, which include the design ground motion, site amplification factors, and seismic load factors. These parameters are determined based on the structure's location and soil conditions.

ASCE 7: ASCE 7 also uses seismic design parameters, but the standard incorporates additional factors, such as the structure's performance category and the seismic design category. This approach results in more customized design parameters that better account for the specific needs of each project.


Seismic Load Factors and Combinations

NBCC: The NBCC prescribes seismic load factors and load combinations for the design of structures. The standard specifies load factors for the main seismic loads, such as dead, live, and snow loads, as well as additional loads related to seismic events, such as accidental torsion.

ASCE 7: ASCE 7 also prescribes seismic load factors and load combinations, but the standard provides more detailed guidance on the selection and application of these factors. The load factors and combinations in ASCE 7 are tailored to the specific performance category and seismic design category, resulting in more accurate estimates of the structure's response during seismic events.


Conclusion

Understanding the differences between NBCC and ASCE 7 in structural performance categories and design requirements is essential for engineers working on seismic design projects. The distinctions in structural performance categories, design requirements based on performance categories, seismic design parameters, and seismic load factors and combinations can significantly impact the design and performance of structures during seismic events. By recognizing these differences, engineers can select the most appropriate standard for their projects and ensure the safety and performance of structures in earthquake-prone regions.



Read more:

Located in Calgary, AlbertaVancouver, BCToronto, OntarioEdmonton, AlbertaHouston TexasTorrance, CaliforniaEl Segundo, CAManhattan Beach, CA; Concord, CA; We offer our engineering consultancy services across Canada and United States. Meena Rezkallah.

bottom of page